Living in downtown Nashville vs. the suburbs: What buyers need to know

Discover the allure of downtown Nashville’s skyline and dynamic lifestyle—contrasted with the peaceful charm of the suburbs, offering options for every buyer.

---

When deciding which part of Nashville to call home, you’ll come across this important question: is the dynamic, fast-paced lifestyle of downtown or the relaxed charm of the suburbs better for you? Each option offers a distinctive way of life, unique real estate opportunities, and strong investment potential.

THE SITUATION

At the heart of the decision is lifestyle. Do you thrive in the rhythm of the city streets or prefer the tranquility of a spacious backyard? Would you trade skyline views for room to spread out? Your preferences and investment goals are the compass for finding the perfect fit.

DOWNTOWN NASHVILLE VS. THE SUBURBS: AN IN-DEPTH COMPARISON

Choosing between Downtown Nashville’s vibrant urban energy and the serene charm of its suburbs is no small decision. Here’s a detailed guide to help you make the right choice.

Lifestyle

Your lifestyle sets the tone for where you’ll feel most at home, whether that’s in the heart of downtown Nashville or any of the city’s suburbs. Let’s break it down and explore how each option aligns with your daily rhythm.

Downtown Nashville: Where the action is

Living in downtown Nashville, you’ll be immersed in the city’s non-stop energy and situated near some of Nashville’s best-known attractions. Picture this: stepping out of your front door and being just minutes away from live music venues, world-class restaurants, and trendy rooftop bars. For those who thrive on excitement, this is where the magic happens.

Perks of downtown living:

• Walkability: Everything you need—coffee shops, boutiques, and nightlife—is within walking distance.
• Cultural experiences: From the Ryman Auditorium to the Country Music Hall of Fame, you’re in the thick of Nashville’s rich culture.
• Networking opportunities: Proximity to offices and coworking spaces make it a hub for young professionals.
• Minimal commutes: Forget long drives; many downtown residents can walk or bike to work.

Of course, the urban buzz comes with some trade-offs. Downtown living often means smaller apartments or condos, limited parking, and less privacy– sacrifices for being in the heart of it all.

Suburban Nashville: Room to breathe

If Downtown feels like a constant concert, the suburbs are more like a cozy acoustic set—relaxed, inviting, and family-friendly. Suburban life means spacious homes, quieter streets, and access to top-notch schools. It’s the ideal choice for families or anyone who prefers a more laid-back pace.

Perks of suburban living:

• More space: Larger lots, multi-bedroom homes, and expansive yards are the norm.
• Community feel: Many suburban neighborhoods have a tight-knit vibe with local events and welcoming neighbors.
• Outdoor access: Parks, walking trails, and open green spaces are abundant.
• Privacy: With fewer crows and noise, you get a true retreat at the end of the day.

On the flip side, suburban life usually means longer commutes and more dependence on a car to get to work, restaurants, or entertainment. But for many, the extra space and tranquility are worth it.

Property types and pricing

Charming homes with vibrant facades and spacious yards– suburban Nashville is where community and comfort come together.

---

The price of real estate– and your selection– is another important factor to consider when choosing between living in Downtown Nashville, TN or the suburbs.

Downtown Nashville: Urban living at a premium

• Property types: The downtown area predominantly features luxury condos and modern apartments. These properties are often equipped with high-end amenities and offer proximity to the city’s cultural scene.
• Pricing: As of October 2024, the median listing home price in downtown Nashville was approximately $799,000. This reflects an 8.7% year-on-year increase.

Nashville suburbs: diverse options for various lifestyles

• Property types: The suburbs offer a diverse array of housing options, including single-family homes, townhouses, and larger estates. These properties usually come with expansive yards and are situated in family-friendly neighborhoods.
• Pricing: It depends. In the broader Nashville area, which includes its suburbs, the median home value stood at $429,694, marking a 0.8% rise over the past year. Certain suburban areas exhibit varied pricing. For instance, Bellevue offers more affordable alternatives in a range of housing options. Green Hills, on the other hand, is more affluent with properties priced for as much as $5 million or more.

Community amenities

Naturally, downtown Nashville and the suburbs offer two sides of the same coin: community amenities. There are some similarities, but the overall experience as well as variety may differ.

In downtown Nashville

• Cultural hotspots: Living downtown, you’ll get unparalleled access to iconic venues like the Ryman Auditorium, the Country Music Hall of Fame, and the Bridgestone Arena. From live music to major events, you’re always close to the action.
• Diverse dining scene: Enjoy a wide range of restaurants, from high-end establishments to low-key eateries, all within walking distance.
• Recreation opportunities: Downtown Nashville is home to green spaces like Riverfront Park and the Bicentennial Capitol Mall State Park. Both of these parks are ideal for picnics, workouts, or admiring the city’s skyline.
• Luxury living: Many downtown properties include upscale amenities such as rooftop pools, state-of-the-art fitness centers, and concierge services that elevate day-to-day living.
• Year-round events: Festivals, art shows, and community celebrations bring residents together and create a dynamic neighborhood atmosphere.

In the suburbs

• Parks and trails: Suburban areas are rich in outdoor amenities, with ample parks, walking trails, and green spaces where residents can enjoy the fresh air and some forms of recreation. Popular spots include Crockett Park in Brentwood or Pinkerton Park in Franklin.
• Family-friendly features: Many suburbs happen to be located near highly rated schools as well as playgrounds and sports facilities.
• Community events: Neighborhoods often host local farmers’ markets, seasonal festivals, and gatherings to help foster a tight-knit community.
• Access to retail and services: There’s shopping and dining to be had in the suburbs, too! Areas such as Franklin and Hendersonville combine charm and convenience with their retail centers, local boutiques, and restaurants.
• Peace and quiet: Compared to the hustle and bustle of downtown, the suburbs generally provide a quieter and more laid-back environment– one where you can truly relax at the end of the day.

Getting around

Another factor you might be taking into consideration is accessibility. When comparing downtown Nashville and its surrounding suburbs, several key differences emerge that might impact your daily commuting experience and overall convenience.

Downtown Nashville: Compact and connected

• Walkability: Being a much smaller area compared to most suburban neighborhoods, downtown Nashville is highly walkable. Numerous attractions, restaurants, and entertainment venues are located within minutes from each other. Moreover, downtown Nashville has approximately 70 miles of sidewalks– a feature that greatly enhances pedestrian movement in the urban core.
• Public transit: Adding to the convenience, downtown Nashville is plied by multiple bus routes that connect to various parts of the city thanks to WeGo Public Transit. The central hub, Music City Central, facilitates seamless transfers between routes.
• Alternative transportation: If you don’t want to walk or take the bus, you’ll have access to electric bike rentals in downtown Nashville through Nashville BCycle. Additionally, ride-sharing services like Uber and Lyft are readily available.

Broadway in Downtown Nashville—where vibrant lights, live music, and the city’s unmistakable energy come alive.

---

Suburban Nashville

• Car dependency: Compared to downtown Nashville, the city’s suburban areas may be more car-dependent. While WeGo Public Transit extends services to some suburbs, the frequency and coverage are generally less comprehensive than in the downtown area.
• Commuter rail: The WeGo Star commuter rail line serves as a vital link between certain suburban neighborhoods and downtown Nashville, with stations in areas like Donelson, Hermitage, and Mt. Juliet. This service offers a viable alternative to driving, especially if you want to avoid the traffic during peak hours.
• Park and ride: If you’re commuting from the suburbs, WeGo also provides Park & Ride facilities. There, you can park your car in a designated lot and use public transit to reach your destination. This effectively reduces the stress of driving and parking in the city center.

Investment potential

Nashville’s real estate market is booming, and both downtown and the surrounding suburbs present unique opportunities for investors like you. As you weigh your options, consider the type of return you’re looking for and how involved you want to be.

Investing in downtown Nashville

Downtown Nashville offers strong potential for short-term rental income as it appeals to professionals, tourists, and anyone craving an urban lifestyle. However, entry costs are higher due to increased property values, and the market? It can be competitive. Additionally, regulatory changes affecting short-term rentals may impact this type of investment.

But if you’re only planning on purchasing a primary residence, there is no question you’ll be able to build equity and enjoy some real estate appreciation in downtown Nashville.

Investing in the suburbs

In the suburbs, the focus shifts towards long-term stability and appreciation. Suburban areas like Franklin and East Nashville are rapidly growing, attracting families and renters looking for more space and a slower-paced lifestyle. Properties here tend to have lower upfront costs compared to downtown, making them more accessible for investors. Plus larger homes with yards and proximity to top-rated schools are highly desirable.

Future development and growth

Nashville’s real estate market is on an exciting trajectory, with Downtown and the suburbs each experiencing significant development tailored to different lifestyles and investment strategies.

Downtown Nashville is transforming into a vertical hub of luxury and convenience. Projects like the towering Paramount Tower and the mixed-use Nashville Yards are reshaping the skyline with high-end residential options, entertainment venues, and state-of-the-art office spaces. These developments cater to professionals and investors seeking urban energy and walkable access to culture, dining, and nightlife. Downtown’s growth promises strong appreciation potential, but with higher entry costs and a fast-paced market, it’s best suited for those ready to navigate its competitive landscape.

Meanwhile, Nashville’s suburbs are expanding outward, offering a more spacious and community-focused lifestyle. Neighborhoods like Donelson and areas along Nolensville Road are attracting attention with new developments that blend residential, retail, and recreational spaces. Suburbs like Franklin and Brentwood continue to thrive, thanks to their family-friendly environments, excellent schools, and room for larger homes. For long-term investors, these areas provide steady growth and a broader range of price points.

What sets them apart?

• Downtown developments focus on high-density, luxury urban living with strong short-term rental potential and quick appreciation.
• Suburban growth leans toward family-oriented spaces, larger properties, and a sense of tranquility, ideal for long-term stability.

Whether you’re drawn to the vibrant buzz of Downtown Nashville or the serene appeal of its suburbs, both areas are brimming with opportunities to align with your lifestyle and investment goals.

An aerial view of Nashville’s suburbs, showcasing spacious homes, lush greenery, and the charm of a peaceful neighborhood.

---

LET’S FIND YOUR PERFECT NASHVILLE HOME TOGETHER

Deciding between Downtown Nashville and the suburbs is a big step, and as someone who’s been helping buyers navigate this amazing city for years, we’re here to make it easier. I’m Lisa Culp Taylor, and along with my incredible team at LCT Team – Onward Real Estate, we specialize in helping clients find the perfect home that fits their lifestyle, needs, and dreams.

Whether you’re drawn to the energy of downtown or the peaceful retreat of the suburbs, we’ll guide you every step of the way. We’re passionate about what we do, we love our clients (and their pets!), and we work tirelessly to make deals happen. Plus, we’re fun, professional, and easy to work with—finding your dream home doesn’t have to feel like a chore!

Give us a call at 615.300.8285 or shoot us an email to get started.